Remember me

Management dilemma: I can’t spare my best people for sabbaticals

Posted on 25 September 2008





On the coaching couch, by Janet Wright

The question 

In a recent annual appraisal a member of my staff asked if they could take a sabbatical to do some charity work abroad. I know very little about this topic and was taken off guard. However, I do know that these types of sabbaticals are becoming more and more popular with companies as a means to both retain and develop staff.

While I am supportive of this request, the truth is that I cannot spare this individual right now. He is a critical resource on a very large IT development project that we are working on and I cannot possibly manage without him. I feel that I’m in a lose-lose situation; whatever I do will jeopardize the project. Can you suggest a way out?

Janet answers 

First of all remember that nobody is indispensable. What would you do if this individual was taken seriously ill or worse? You would cope. Perhaps not particularly elegantly but you’d find a way.

Now having said that let’s take a few steps back, as well as a few deep breaths and review the situation. There is nothing in your question that leads me to believe that this

individual expects to leave on a sabbatical tomorrow. To be frank he would not be worth the value you clearly place on him if he did. You admit to being caught ‘off guard’ so I am sure you said you would give it some thought and get back to him. At this present time I would imagine this individual is only interested in knowing whether you would entertain the notion of a sabbatical or not.

Before you give your answer there are a number of aspects to consider:

  1. What is your company’s policy on employees taking extended leave?  If there is no precedent or your superiors are unsupportive then do you have surplus energy to divert to this cause?  However, if you believe a sabbatical is a real possibility then …
  2. Find out from HR what is required (from you and your employee) in order to make this happen. What are the risks involved to personal safety? Has your company aligned itself with a particular charity or cause in the ‘developing world’? What does the company expect in return for granting this request? How will you back-fill his position? Working with developing world charities can be a little different from working in a high tech industry. What windows of opportunity for voluntary work abroad are there? In this case…
  3. When would be the earliest you could spare this individual? I’m sure you are working to a project plan which both you and your employee is familiar with. Once you are clear about the best fit solution for the project it would be well worth sitting down with this individual and sharing your thoughts with him. You never know he may have some creative ideas of his own and getting buy-in to a release date is key to retention. And as retention is clearly a concern…
  4. Do you know why this employee has asked for time out?

Is he burnt out and seeking a worthy way to recharge his batteries? Perhaps, although the project is on the critical path, he does not find the work challenging enough and is bored. Perhaps he is seeking an exit strategy and there is nothing you can do to keep him. So granting a sabbatical will just be delaying the inevitable (and wasting your company’s time and money). If you work closely with this individual I’m sure you will have your suspicions; so is a sabbatical the right solution?

There would be very little point in actively pursuing an extended leave of absence if another course of action would be more appropriate. Now that your employee has raised the question of a sabbatical and you have had time to do some investigation of your own it will probably pay dividends to sit back down with him to understand exactly what he expects to achieve from this. Then you can explore how it might be possible to meet both his expectations and your desire to keep the project on track.

In answer to your question, all is not lost – don’t give away your control. Face the situation with all the facts in front of you and seek the best fit solution for everyone, your employee, you and your company. All that is required to turn a lose-lose into a win-win is wise negotiation and the willingness to compromise.

Categories: On the coaching couch ,

Comments

All comments

You need to be registered with the IET to leave a comment. Please log in or register as a new user.